Testimonials

What Our Customers are Saying

Schaeffer Homes reviews and comments at GuildQuality Schaeffer Homes works with GuildQuality to conduct third party testimonials after you sign your Construction Agreement, shortly after you move into your home and then again after 11 months living in your home. We take great pride in being an 8-time winner of the Guildmaster Award, which requires that at least 90% of our customers would recommend friends and family to Schaeffer Homes.

Guildmaster with Distinction 2026 In 2026, we were awarded Guildmaster with Distinction, which requires a recommendation rate between 95.0% and 97.9%. We are proud to be New Jersey’s only Guildmaster builder and the only Guildmaster builder in 100% of the markets we serve across NJ, PA, DE and MD. We want to sincerely thank our homeowners for their continued trust and support. This achievement would not be possible without you!

Schaeffer Homes

4.4 out of 5 star rating from GuildQuality308 Reviews

Evan A.

Feb 6, 2026 · Voorhees, NJ
Rated 5

Expertise

Our project manager Maria was wonderful and really took charge of getting our home completed

Schedule

Schedule got disrupted minimal times, biggest with the cabinet redo, but the team worked through it

Project Manager Professionalism

Would highly recommend Maria to anyone, she went above and beyond with our construction

Problem Resolution

When we did have problems, Schaeffer did resolve and work with us to find a solution

Areas Of Satisfaction

The home itself came out wonderful, the layout is great and we love having the sunroom and 3 car gar... Read more

Recognized Excellence

Definitely Maria Zeris :)

Additional Comments

While it definitely was a journey to get our construction over the finish line, I'm glad we chose Sc... Read more

Sandra M.

Feb 3, 2026 · Port Norris, NJ
Rated 5

Sales Attentiveness

Joseph is very responsive and detailed in his communications.

Understand Building Process

Appreciate that everything is laid out clearly.

Reviewer in Frenchtown, NJ

Oct 24, 2025 · Frenchtown, NJ
Rated 4

Overall, I am very pleased with the quality of the work provided by Schaeffer. I am grateful for... Read more

Construction Quality

I am very happy with the quality of materials and workmanship of my Schaeffer home.

Project Manager Professionalism

I can not speak highly enough of Van and his dedication to the project. From day one, we work collab... Read more

Value

I researched several options for constructing a home on my lot and feel that Schaeffer offered the b... Read more

Bosede F.

Oct 12, 2025 · Somerset, NJ
Rated 4

The land development department could do better

Sales Attentiveness

Lisa was exceptionally kind and attentive

Patrick D.

Aug 23, 2025 · Warwick, MD
Rated 4

Sales Attentiveness

Keith was extremely helpful during the review and consideration process. We had a good understanding... Read more

Understand Building Process

The handbook clearly defines the home building process.

Design Center & Selections

Ashley answered all of our questions and made the process easy.

William M.

May 18, 2025 · Barnegat, NJ
Rated 5

Very helpful understanding process.

Reviewer in Little Egg Harbor, NJ

Mar 7, 2025 · Little Egg Harbor, NJ
Rated 5

Project Manager Professionalism

Jason Downey is very professional!

Stoyan K.

Dec 30, 2024 · Egg Harbor City, NJ
Rated 4

So far I am pleased with Schaeffer Homes, but we are just at the beginning of the process, and I... Read more

Bruce S.

Dec 30, 2024 · Collingswood, NJ
Rated 5

Schaeffer has been great to work with through this process and took the time to answer all my... Read more

Janie P.

Dec 23, 2024 · Mount Laurel, NJ
Rated 5

I have already recommended Schaeffer Homes to a few friends based on how quickly they can put a... Read more